Hazel Brannon Smith was almost certainly the most unpopular woman in Mississippi when she wrote an editorial in 1963. Today, newspapers face a different crisis: the disappearance of the editorial itself.
The long history of newspaper editorials may be about to end, a casualty of both changing news values and economic pressure. Nominations for the Pulitzer Prize for editorials peaked in 1995 with 101 entries, but declined to just 25 this year, according to Pulitzer Prizes administrator Marjorie Miller.
Since the birth of this nation, newspapers have published editorials challenging the powerful and calling for reform. From William Lloyd Garrison’s call for the abolition of slavery in the Boston-based Liberator to The Bainbridge Review’s 1942 condemnation of Japanese American internment, editorials have played a role in virtually every important social and justice movement in American history.
On the local level, newspaper editorials tend to address more mundane yet essential topics: supporting local schools, monitoring the use of taxpayer dollars, and calling out ineffective government processes. They represent the voice of institutional journalism at its best.
However, major news companies have backed away. Gannett, now USA Today Co. Inc. and the largest newspaper company in the U.S., and Lee Enterprises, the third largest, led the scaling back of local editorials beginning in 2022. Gannett was candid about its reasons: editorials were frequently cited by readers as a reason for canceling their subscriptions. Speaking truth to power was affecting the bottom line.
Some argue that readers don’t want newspapers telling them what to think. But this misses the point. Good editorials don’t dictate; they balance ideas and look out for a community with the perspective of a longtime resident. USA Today pioneered dual editorials, offering both its view and a differing perspective.
Despite the trend away from editorials, recent research indicates that readers remain hungry for public accountability. A Pew Research study found in 2024 that most Americans believe criticism from news organisations keeps political leaders from doing things they shouldn’t. The public wants accountability, and newspapers that abandon their editorial voice may be losing more than they realise.
The challenge facing the publishing industry is whether it can afford to restore what it has lost. In an era of declining subscription revenues and economic pressure, investing in local editorials seems like a luxury many publishers can no longer justify. Yet the consequences of this decision extend far beyond the industry itself. Without the institutional voice of local newspapers holding power accountable, communities lose an essential check on government and corporate behaviour.
Good editorials represent a newspaper’s commitment to its community. They are not just opinion pieces but the institutional conscience of journalism. Whether the industry will invest in recovering this voice remains to be seen. For readers and democracy alike, the answer matters deeply.









